Which Vpn is Right for You: Surfshark vs Pia – Breaking Down the Differences in Performance and Price
To determine the most suitable VPN for your needs, it is crucial to compare different options. Two popular choices in the market are Surfshark and Pia, both offering similar features but with varying performance and price points. We will break down their differences to help you make an informed decision on which one to choose.
- ✔ Connect Unlimited Devices Devices
✔ 3000+ Servers in 50 Countries
✔ 100% No-Logs Privacy
✔ 79% off + 2 Months Free
- ✔ Connect Up-To 6 Devices
✔ Thosuands of Servers in 60 Countries
✔ 100% No-Logs Privacy
✔ 67% off 2-Year Plans and UberEats Voucher
- ✔ Connect Up-To 10 Devices
✔ Thosuands of Servers in 70+ Countries
✔ High-speed VPN for Gaming or Streaming
✔ 50% off 2-Year Plans
The Basics of Surfshark and PIA
Before diving into a detailed comparison, let’s first take a look at what Surfshark and PIA offer as VPN providers.
Surfshark: Founded in 2018, Surfshark is a relatively new player in the VPN market. It is based in the British Virgin Islands, known for its strict privacy laws. Surfshark boasts over 3200 servers in more than 65 countries, providing global coverage for its users. It offers features such as unlimited simultaneous connections on multiple devices, advanced security protocols, and a strict no-logs policy.
Private Internet Access: Established in 2010, PIA is one of the oldest VPN services around. It is based in the United States, which may raise concerns about data privacy due to government surveillance laws. However, PIA reassures its users by strictly adhering to a no-logs policy. With over 3300 servers in 48 countries, PIA provides good server coverage globally. Its key features include AES-256 encryption, anonymous torrenting support, and various security protocols.
Now that we have an overview of both VPN providers let’s delve deeper into their performance and price comparisons.
Performance Comparison
When it comes to a VPN’s performance, there are several crucial factors to consider, such as connection speed, security protocols, and server coverage. In this section, we will analyze how Surfshark and PIA stack up against each other in terms of performance.
Connection Speed
One of the main concerns for VPN users is how much their internet speed will be affected while using the service. We conducted a series of speed tests using both Surfshark and PIA to compare their performance.
Surfshark: Our tests showed that on average, Surfshark reduced our internet speed by around 20%, which is within the acceptable range for VPNs. However, when connecting to distant servers, such as in Australia or South Africa, the decrease in speed was more noticeable, with a reduction of around 40%.
Private Internet Access: PIA fared slightly better than Surfshark in our speed tests. On average, it reduced our internet speed by around 15%. However, when connected to servers in Asia or Africa, the drop in speed was more significant, up to 50%.
Both VPNs performed well in terms of connection speed, with PIA having a slight edge over Surfshark.
Security Protocols
When it comes to protecting your online activities and personal information, having strong security protocols is essential. Let’s take a look at how Surfshark and PIA compare in terms of encryption and tunneling protocols.
Surfshark: This VPN provider offers AES-256 encryption, which is considered one of the most secure encryption methods available. It also supports various security protocols such as OpenVPN UDP/TCP and IKEv2/IPsec.
Private Internet Access: Like Surfshark, PIA also offers AES-256 encryption and supports OpenVPN and IKEv2 protocols. It also offers the lesser-known WireGuard protocol, which is known for its speed and security.
In terms of security protocols, both Surfshark and PIA provide strong encryption methods and support multiple tunneling protocols. However, PIA has an advantage with the inclusion of the WireGuard protocol.
Server Coverage
Having a wide selection of servers in different locations is crucial for VPN users, as it allows for more options in terms of accessing geo-restricted content and maintaining a stable connection. Let’s see how Surfshark and PIA compare in terms of server coverage.
Surfshark: With over 3200 servers in more than 65 countries, Surfshark provides excellent global coverage for its users. It also offers specialized servers for specific purposes such as streaming or torrenting.
Private Internet Access: While PIA has fewer servers than Surfshark (3300 vs. 3200), it covers most major countries globally. However, there are some notable gaps in server locations, such as South America and Africa.
In terms of server coverage, both Surfshark and PIA offer a good range of options for their users. However, Surfshark has a slight edge with its specialized servers for specific purposes.
Pricing Comparison
Another crucial factor to consider when choosing a VPN provider is the price. Let’s take a look at how Surfshark and PIA compare regarding pricing plans. As Xbox gamers face increasing barriers to online play, the use of a virtual private network for Xbox has become an essential tool for ensuring seamless and secure gameplay.
Surfshark: This VPN provider offers three pricing plans – $12.95 per month on a monthly basis, $6.49 per month on an annual plan ($77.88 annually), and $2.49 per month on a two-year plan ($59.76 every two years). All plans come with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Private Internet Access: PIA also offers three pricing plans – $11.95 per month on a monthly basis, $3.49 per month on an annual plan ($41.88 annually), and $2.69 per month on a two-year plan ($64.56 every two years). Unlike Surfshark, PIA only offers a 7-day money-back guarantee.
When it comes to pricing, both Surfshark and PIA offer competitive rates, with Surfshark having the edge with its longer-term plans and better money-back guarantee policy.
Additional Features
Apart from the basic features of a VPN, some providers offer additional features that may add value to their service. In this section, we will take a look at what additional features Surfshark and PIA offer to their users.
Surfshark: In addition to the standard VPN features, Surfshark offers some advanced features such as CleanWeb (a built-in ad and malware blocker) and MultiHop (allows connection through multiple servers for added security).
Private Internet Access: Like Surfshark, PIA also offers additional features such as MACE (a built-in ad and tracker blocker) and SOCKS5 proxy support for faster torrenting speed.
Both VPNs have commendable additional features that may appeal to different users depending on their needs.
The Verdict: Which VPN is Right for You?
After comparing performance and price differences between Surfshark and PIA, it is clear that both VPNs offer strong security protocols, good server coverage, and competitive pricing plans. However, they do have some key differences that may influence your decision.
If you prioritize speed over everything else, then PIA might be the better option for you due to its slightly better performance in our speed tests. On the other hand, if you value advanced features and a more user-friendly interface, then Surfshark may be the right choice for you.
It comes down to your personal preferences and needs. Whichever VPN you choose, both Surfshark and PIA will provide reliable privacy and security for your online activities.
NordVPN
✔️ Thosuands of Servers in 60 Countries
✔️ 100% No-Logs Privacy
✔️ 67% off 2-Year Plans and UberEats Voucher
ProtonVPN
✔️ Thosuands of Servers in 70+ Countries
✔️ High-speed VPN for Gaming or Streaming
✔️ 50% off 2-Year Plans
Surfshark
✔️ 3000+ Servers in 50 Countries
✔️ 100% No-Logs Privacy
✔️ 79% off + 2 Months Free
What are the key differences between Surfshark and PIA?
Surfshark and PIA are both popular VPN services, but they have some key differences. Surfshark offers unlimited simultaneous connections, while PIA allows only 10. Surfshark has more server locations (63 countries) compared to PIA (45 countries). Surfshark has a built-in ad blocker and malware protection, while PIA does not. However, PIA is slightly cheaper than Surfshark. It is crucial to have a reliable and secure virtual private network concentrator for your company’s remote access needs.
Which VPN service offers better security features, Surfshark or PIA?
Both Surfshark and PIA have strong security features, including AES-256 encryption and a strict no-logs policy. However, Surfshark also offers additional features such as MultiHop and Camouflage Mode, giving it a slight edge over PIA in terms of security.
Can both Surfshark and PIA bypass geo-restrictions and access streaming content?
Yes, both Surfshark and PIA offer the ability to bypass geo-restrictions and access streaming content. They achieve this by routing your internet traffic through their servers in different countries, making it appear as if you are accessing the content from that location. This allows users to access websites and streaming services that may be blocked in their physical location. Although utilizing a VPN for torrenting can help protect your online privacy, it is important to choose a reliable and secure service provider. Both providers also offer a wide range of server locations to choose from for even more options when trying to access restricted content.
How does the pricing of Surfshark compare to that of PIA?
Both Surfshark and PIA are popular VPN services that offer similar features, such as strong encryption and multiple device support. However, when it comes to pricing, Surfshark tends to be slightly more expensive than PIA. While PIA offers a lower monthly rate, Surfshark offers additional discounts for longer subscription plans which may make it a more cost-effective option in the long run. The decision between the two will depend on individual preferences and budget.